29 March, 2024

Our Future: as Evangelicals?

by | 25 April, 2017 | 6 comments

By Mark A. Taylor

Are members of Christian churches and churches of Christ properly categorized as Evangelicals?

We addressed this topic in the first year I served as editor of CHRISTIAN STANDARD*, and now as I close my tenure, I wonder if anyone is still asking the question.

The two who answered in 2003 wrote passionately and convincingly and came to completely opposite conclusions.

Alexander Campbell (left) and James DeForest Murch. Murch was the first managing editor of Christianity Today.

William R. Baker described James DeForest Murch”s decision to boldly identify himself with the growing Evangelical movement in the 1940s and afterwards. “Not since Isaac Errett, founding editor of CHRISTIAN STANDARD, had anyone from the Restoration Movement thrust himself so thoroughly into a position of leadership among evangelicals,” Baker wrote. He cited Murch”s role as editor of the National Association of Evangelicals journal, as president of several prominent Evangelical organizations, and as the first managing editor of Christianity Today.

Baker also described Alexander Campbell”s careful examination and general endorsement of nine “evangelical principles” stated by the formational meeting of the Evangelical Alliance in 1846.

“Campbell senses and expresses a deep kinship with the Evangelical Alliance,” Baker wrote. “Were Campbell alive today, I believe he would be a prominent ETS [Evangelical Theological Society] member and a consulting editor for Christianity Today.”

But Robert F. Hull urged against placing ourselves in the Evangelical camp, for two reasons:

First, “We have nothing to gain.” He wrote:

We have traditionally understood ourselves to be, not a denomination, or a sect, or church, but rather, a movement within the whole church, calling the church to continual reformation of its life and practice by means of the spiritual standards of the New Testament.

Hull urges us to stick with our historic plea to be just Christians, without limiting ourselves with any “ism” that subdivides Christianity.

Second, he says, “We have much to lose.”

If we settle down into the evangelical camp, we will surrender two critical convictions that have been characteristic of the Stone-Campbell heritage: a high view of the church and a high view of the sacraments (or ordinances). . . .

What is striking and significant is that our high view of the church and the sacraments is not something distinctive about the Stone-Campbell Movement: it is just the opposite. Our theology of the church and the sacraments has been shared with most Christian people during most of the history of the church. We are closer to the Episcopalians than the Baptists in this regard. To give up these historic emphases would be a serious loss.

But I”ve concluded we are on the verge of experiencing that loss. My thinking on this crystallized in my response to an assignment I fulfilled last week around this topic: “The Future of the Restoration Movement.”

We speak of our “tribe,” I said in my workshop. But, increasingly, we look and sound like most of the rest of the Evangelical world.

We read the same books, attend the same conferences, use the same worship music, buy Bible teaching materials from the same sources, advocate the same strategies and solutions for ministry, quote the same theologians, and send our kids to the same Christian colleges (if we send them to Christian colleges at all).

Evangelical Christians moving from town to town, or church shoppers in our own communities, choose our congregations the same way we choose our ministry sources: on the basis of features and benefits, what looks good and what seems to work””not because of a shared or vital, unique theological commitment or heritage beyond a basic allegiance to Jesus as Lord, and, probably, to the Bible as authoritative and inspired.

And those sacraments Hull mentioned, the role of baptism in salvation and the place of the Lord”s Supper at the center of worship, are widely minimalized among us.

Any discussion about the future of our movement must acknowledge that in practice, if not by intent, our movement as a distinct factor in the church today is little appreciated if not stridently avoided by many identified with our group.

Does this matter? Only history will tell. But a movement without a compelling rallying cry will soon lose its reason to exist. There”s no doubt our movement is still moving. But the question is whether that activity is in response to our unique calling or as a reflection of prompts coming largely from the Evangelical subset.

Hull challenged readers to think of our movement and its plea as larger than Evangelicalism. But the time may come when we shrink into identity as something smaller. 

*See the March 16, 2003, issue, pp. 4ff.

6 Comments

  1. Andy Baker

    I see both sides of the argument but find myself in agreement with Dr. Hull, my former professor. I am saddened by the lesser role given to the sacraments, and I do believe we are all too quick to embrace the Willow Creeks (Reformed) and Saddlebacks (Baptist) because of their methods leading to megachurch success. I do believe the call of our movement has been lost to societal changes of success, or even more frequently, we are catering to a consumer mentality. Mark, you are spot-on with your conclusions. Somewhere along the way we lost our way. Our movement used to have great leaders and our schools were thriving. To me, our future as a movement looks bleak.

  2. Eric Miller

    “But a movement without a compelling rallying cry will soon lose its reason to exist. There”™s no doubt our movement is still moving. But the question is whether that activity is in response to our unique calling or as a reflection of prompts coming largely from the Evangelical subset.”

    Profound.

    I began attending one of our universities, where I am still at, for the purpose of training to be a preacher in the Christian Churches, but later went back on a lifetime of expectations for many of the reasons listed in this article. If I wanted to be evangelical, I would have joined an evangelical church. I believed in our history and our distinctives, not to the exclusion of all others, but to the addition of all the unique things Bible-believing traditions have to bring to the table of Christian fellowship.

    Why is it when people want us to “dissolve” or “sink” it’s only in reference to the evangelicals? Why not Presbyterians or Anglicans or Brethren? Maybe because this language is simply an easy excuse to just keep doing what we’re doing in an unhindered embrace of non-distinct evangelicalism. Rick Atchley warned about this, as have many others.

    I have begun searching for a spiritual home outside the Christian Churches and Churches of Christ, gravitating toward the German Brethren. However, I will always be a son of the Restoration Movement. The Restoration Movement is not only bigger than evangelicals; it is bigger than the independent Christian Churches. This gives me some solace.

    I appreciate Mark Taylor for this difficult to read but much appreciated article.

  3. Jordan

    Thanks for this. I am seeing a lot of conversations like this. It may be of interest to everyone that Great Lakes Christian College put together last year (and will again this) a Restoration Movement Appreciation Week. One of the speakers, Dr. John Nugent, proposed some thoughts toward a “New Wave of Restorationism”: https://www.glcc.edu/content/uploads/2016/09/Nugent-A-New-Wave.pdf

    This is an important conversation, especially for younger ministers like myself. I look forward to hearing more.

  4. Stephen Lawson

    I think Taylor is absolutely correct in his description of what is happening in many of our churches. I agree with my former professor Dr. Hull that such developments are troubling.

    This whole discussion reminds me of an article I wrote in the Stone-Campbell Journal on William Robinson, the British theologian of the Stone-Campbell Movement.

    I concluded that article by writing, “In my view an unconsidered adoption of generic Evangelical practice and doctrine into Stone-Campbell churches is in many cases an abandonment of the restoration plea for unity within truth. I would suggest it is frequently a pragmatic and passive lowest-common denominator Christianity that diminishes particular ecclesial identity, often through the use of corporatized sociological practices. The significance of the Stone-Campbell plea, I believe, is not that it gives us grounds to sink into the ocean of American Evangelicalism but that it allows and even requires us to exist in the paradoxical tension that Robinson articulated and embodied in his own life, ‘catholic yet ever evangelical.'”

    For me, Robinson represents the best of what the our movement has to offer. I’m not trying to be self-promoting, but you can read the whole article by following the link below. I just want more people to know and appreciate Robinson.

    https://www.academia.edu/27504231/Free_Church_Catholic_The_Legacy_of_William_Robinson

  5. Daer Platt

    Anyone else appreciate the irony of the respective schools with which Drs. Baker and Hull were associated, given their respective viewpoints?

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Latest Articles

Ministry Help Wanted

Recent postings: Impact Christian Church (Moon Township, Pa.) is seeking an executive pastor. The Christian Campus Foundation (CCF) at the University of Illinois is seeking a full-time director of campus ministry. New Brighton (Minn.) Christian Church needs a new senior minister. Summit Christian College (Gering, Neb.) is accepting applications for the position of academic dean. And more . . .

Stories

By taking these symbols of Jesus’ body and blood, we announce we believe there really was a Jesus, and he really did die for us and carried all our sins down to a grave . . .

Documentary Highlights Christian Response to Pandemics

Southeast Christian Church’s “Purpose in Pandemics” is a documentary that follows the response of the church to pandemics throughout history. The “Purpose in Pandemics” website also includes a study guide for small groups and individuals.

Used of God

I soaked up Sam Stone’s wit and wisdom during our lunches together. Afterward, I’d take notes about our conversations. After hearing of his passing, inspired by his wordsmithing, I felt compelled to share just a small part of his story.

Sam E. Stone: ‘He Tried to Speak the Truth in Love’

In memory and appreciation of our former editor, Sam E. Stone, who died early this week, we share this 2011 column from Christian Standard’s archives in which Sam discussed four Scripture verses significant to his life.

Elliott Library ‘Cornerstone’ Laid

Three Bibles of historical significance to Cincinnati Christian University were the first books place on the shelves during relocation of the George Mark Elliott Library.

The Death of Evil

Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. saw in minority groups’ struggles for social equality in America a parallel with Israel’s bondage in Egypt. King envisioned God’s goodness would deliver the U.S. from the evil of segregation.

Mark Scott’s Greatest Kingdom Impact

Since I first enrolled at Ozark Christian College, Mark Scott has been my kingdom hero, and I’m not the only young preacher Mark has shaped. Over his 35 years at OCC, Mark has inspired generations of students.

‘Have We Plans for 1921?’

“All the Standard asks is the opportunity to serve, and it yearns to render in 1921 the greatest, finest, and best service of its history. . . .”

News Briefs for Dec. 9

Items from Timber Lake Christian Church (Moberly, Mo.), Choateville Christian Church (Frankfort, Ky.), Johnson University, and more.

My Counsel for Young Preachers

If I were counseling an aspiring young preacher fresh out of Bible college or seminary, champing at the bit to lead in the church, I would offer these three bits of advice.

My Memories of Marshall Leggett

By Ben Merold
As I think about Marshall Leggett, who passed away on March 2 at age 90, two personal experiences keep coming to my mind . . .

Powell Quintuplets Graduating from High School

When the Powell quintuplets were born in 2001, all of Kentucky celebrated, including Southeast Christian Church, where the Powells are longtime members. Now the quints are 18 and are all headed to the same university.

Reentry: It May Be Harder Than We Think

When the COVID-19 crisis eases, I anticipate that reentry is going to be harder than some people think. Churches, especially, need to prepare for this.

THROWBACK THURSDAY: ‘Easter Church Attendance’ (1949)

“This Lord’s Day will find nearly all the churches having the largest crowds of the year,” editor Burris Butler wrote in 1949. “It has become almost proverbial that many people attend church on Easter Sunday who never come at any other time” . . .

News Briefs for March 27

Ozark Christian College has updated their logo. Also, briefs from Harlan (Ky.) Christian Church, Summit Christian College, and the Common Grounds Unity Podcast.

The Best Sermon I Never Heard

“Can I tell you about the best sermon I never heard?” Matt Proctor asked the crowd at ICOM last November. “If I could time travel just once . . . I would go back to Luke 24. On that very first Easter Sunday . . . the resurrected Jesus is walking on the road to Emmaus, talking with two travelers. . . .”

KCU Announces Agreements with LBC, NEOBC

Kentucky Christian University has announced separate agreements to enable those who have earned a bachelor’s degree from Louisville Bible College or Northeast Ohio Bible College to seamlessly transition into the graduate programs offered by KCU’s Keeran School of Bible and Ministry. . . .

Follow Us