Collapsing Culture Brings Family Ruin?
Does religious decline weaken families, or does family breakdown drive secularization? Mark A. Taylor explores Mary Eberstadt's provocative argument and why churches need authentic relationships to strengthen marriages and families.

Family Breakdown and Secularization: What Comes First?
Family breakdown and secularization may be connected in ways that challenge common assumptions about declining religious influence. Mark A. Taylor examines Mary Eberstadt’s argument that weakened family structures contribute to declining religious belief. Drawing on a Beyond the Standard discussion, he considers how churches can strengthen marriages and families through authentic relationships and practical examples.
- Mary Eberstadt argues that weakening family structures may contribute to religious decline rather than simply result from it.
- Healthy families can demonstrate Christian living through everyday relationships and shared experiences.
- Churches may struggle to help marriages when members feel judged or hesitate to acknowledge their difficulties.
The deterioration of Christian influence in our culture has caused the collapse of stable families in our society, right?
Although many conservative Christians believe the above idea, at least one writer challenges it.
Mary Eberstadt, in her book How the West Really Lost God: A New Theory of Secularization, proposes that the collapse of family structures in our country and several others has caused the loss of religious influence, not vice versa.
Quoted by Justin Taylor at The Gospel Coalition website, Eberstadt said:
People are social beings. They learn religion the way they learn language: in communities, beginning with the community of the family. And when family structure becomes disrupted and attenuated and fractured, as it is for many Western people today, many families can no longer function as a transmission belt for religious belief.
In other words, as Jim Street summarized it in CHRISTIAN STANDARD’s August 15 Beyond the Standard BlogTalkRadio program, “The loss of a family’s authority over people may be tied to a culture’s distance from God.”
Family Breakdown and Secularization: The Church’s Challenge
If this is true, then building up families is one of the church’s top priorities. And yet all three of the panel members in our program agreed that making families healthier is a difficult challenge for the church.
This is true because, too often for too many, the church makes little connection with the Christian’s everyday life. “People take their lives to work more than they do to church,” Street said.
“Real relationships have multiple contacts,” Randy Gariss added, but “plastic relationships” have fewer. “Education doesn’t capture the imagination,” he said. People need examples, not classes. People from dysfunctional families discover how healthy families live by seeing them in action, he said—eating with them in their homes, spending time with them in a variety of settings. People respond to models more than another lecture or sermon.
Strengthening Marriages Through Authentic Relationships
Street said you can’t expect to effect real change by doing “drive-by shootings from the pulpit.”
Arron Chambers observed that, “Every marriage has some sort of dysfunction in it, but we don’t know it. Every marriage looks perfect at church.” And sometimes church members are least willing to accept direction for change from their minister. Chambers, who has done marriage coaching with more than 400 couples in the last five years, confessed that it’s easier for him to deal with non-Christians than church members. His experience (it “shocked” him at first): he needs to be much more careful addressing difficult issues head-on with Christian couples. Evidently non-Christians are quicker to admit their weaknesses and “get down to business” about addressing them.
“There’s an atmosphere of judgment more than an atmosphere of understanding” at church, Street observed. “People are hesitant to bring their lives to the church.”
This is just one of several important ideas discussed by Chambers, Gariss, and Street in our latest presentation of Beyond the Standard. Listen to the free hour-long discussion “What About Marriage?” at www.blogtalkradio.com/standardpublishing.
For 160 years Christian Standard has served the churches of the Restoration Movement. Your gift keeps articles like this one free for every church leader.
Keep reading
More in Family & Relationships
From the archive
Christian Standard has covered this since 1866.










