Sad Because She Left Us
Mark A. Taylor reflects on Anne Rice’s disappointment with the church and points instead to the grace, welcome, and authentic community Christians are called to build together.

Anne Rice and the Meaning of Church Community
Mark A. Taylor reflects on Anne Rice’s public decision to separate herself from Christianity’s followers while still claiming faith in Christ. Drawing from his own return to a welcoming church community, Taylor considers the sadness, grace, and responsibility Christians share as members of Christ’s body.
- Taylor contrasts Anne Rice’s disappointment with the church with his own experience of being warmly welcomed back.
- He acknowledges that many people have been hurt or disillusioned by church life.
- The column calls Christians to help make the church a place of mercy, authentic community, and hope.
My wife and I discovered something wonderful when we returned to our church after three vacation Sundays away: people there missed us.
Amid all the friendly pats and hearty greetings—“Welcome back!” “We loved your pictures on Facebook!” “Was your trip wonderful?”—I thought about this column I promised to write when we returned.
This continues a discussion begun in last week’s issue. There I reported on and reacted to author Anne Rice’s public announcement of her decision to walk away from Christianity. She said her faith in Christ is “central” to her life, but “following Christ does not mean following his followers.” She loves Jesus but no longer can identify with the “quarrelsome, hostile, disputatious” group called the church.
The Church Anne Rice Did Not Experience
But none of those adjectives described the happy conversations in the hallway when I came back to church. None fit how I felt when the worship songs washed over me and I lifted my eyes to join the praise. None of those negative feelings came to me when I pondered the preacher’s words and how they should guide my after-vacation lists of responsibilities.
As I wrote last week, Rice’s decision makes me sad—sad because most of us have been disappointed by the church, but also sad because Rice apparently has not experienced the community most of us have found there.
She told a National Public Radio interviewer that her decision has given her a “new freedom to confess my fears, my doubts, my pain, my conflicts, my alienation.” And that makes me sad, too. I’ve experienced and witnessed remarkable grace inside the church. I’m sorry Rice hasn’t.
Choosing Mercy and Authentic Community
We might be inclined to argue with her. We could point out, as others did immediately after her announcement, that it’s impossible to be in Christ without also being in the church. We cannot remain connected to him, the head, if we’re removed from the church, his body.
But her words sparked in me an instinct to ponder more than defend. How many with me in the worship auditorium each week are more disillusioned than encouraged? How can I help make the church a place of mercy as well as judgment? What steps can I take within the church to create authentic community beyond tight, polite appearances? How can I extend the help and hope I regularly find among fellow Christians?
Together we are the church. I’m sorry Anne Rice will not work with us to fill the gaps we are finding and has not experienced the blessings we’re celebrating as members of the body of Christ.
For 160 years Christian Standard has served the churches of the Restoration Movement. Your gift keeps articles like this one free for every church leader.
Keep reading
More in Church Life
From the archive
Christian Standard has covered this since 1866.












