As We Publish Our Hiring Articles

By Mark A. Taylor

A few thoughts occur to me as we post our articles about hiring a minister.

The first of them is spurred by an e-mail that came in response to an article that appeared this summer. I’ll paraphrase in order to protect the identity of the letter writer:

I am a new minister fresh out of seminary in 2009. I took on a small church in my first pastorate, and in a little more than a year I was asked to leave. . . . Now my family and I are trying to find our next ministry while being forced to move out of this church’s parsonage by the end of the month. So far, no doors have been opened enough for us to know what we’re to do, so we are praying hard that in 16 days something will happen.

The writer went on to say thanks for an article that had encouraged him in the midst of this struggle. And while that is gratifying, I can’t help but grieve over the situation this idealistic young man finds himself in.

Of course, this doesn’t tell us the whole story. We don’t know enough to decide who’s “right” here and who’s “wrong” or whether he deserves to be fired.

(I do wonder, however, in situations like this: Do those with the power to dismiss a minister have adult children employed by someone else? Are they treating the minister the way they hope other employers are treating their children?)

The more basic issue surrounds the issue of hiring. If this church had followed the careful procedures outlined in last week’s issue and this one, wouldn’t everyone have had a clearer idea of the commitment they were making to each other? Wouldn’t the candidate have discovered the church leaders’ nonnegotiables? And wouldn’t they have learned the path he thought the church should follow?

Maybe not. But we can think of many difficult situations that could have been prevented—in larger churches as well as smaller—simply by following the careful, straightforward path our writers have described.

Which leads me to another thought: I’m so glad these articles are in print, and so pleased they will stay easily accessible for hiring committees to use in the future.

Remember, the hiring articles in this and last week’s issues are now available in a convenient download. Order “Hiring a New Minister,” item number 025470510DL, from the Standard Publishing Web site ( It contains all this material in one easy-to-use package.

You Might Also Like

1 Comment

  1. Jim
    November 19, 2010 at 2:00 pm

    But there are ways to leave well when asked to resign if the minister will follow them. Some of the best ministry God has in mind spring board off of a forced resignation. I’ve learned 4 keys to effectively resigning when the relationship with the preacher doesn’t work out:

    1. Love first. Remembering during the dating period how much you were loved is critical to beginning the transition on the right footing. Unless an obvious sin issue is involved, most resignations are the result of chemistry not working out.

    2. Listen to your heart. God will fill you with His Spirit when Satan storms in to foster bitterness, resentment and division. Know your heart and ask God to reveal any sin issue that may find its way in

    3. Leave the past behind. The temptation to keep asking, “what if…” will shadow your thinking and stall your progression forward. While you may try to justify why you shouldn’t have been fired, the point is you need to move on. Generally the request for resignation is followed with, “but we’d love for you to stay on as members.” This can come across wrong but if it’s offered, take him up on it.

    4. Learn from others. It’s important to find out what you could do to avoid potential mistakes but this must be done in a spirit of love not in division. Your inquiries of other leaders or members may be mistaken as being divisive if you’re not clear in your support of your church and your preacher and elders.

    5. Live with urgency. Looking for the next full time ministry is a full time job. If you are confident in your abilities, certain of God’s calling and have moral character, move forward with diligence and a strong plan.

    Jim McFarland has his career in the careers industry as well as located ministry. For coaching or encouragement, contact him at 317-694-2758

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Subscribe for Free!

Subscribe to gain free access to all of our digital content,
including our new digital magazine,
and we'll let you know when new digital issues are ready to view!