Hope, Despair in India: Find This Book and Read It! (Part 13)
Jim Tune reviews A Fine Balance by Rohinton Mistry, a heartbreaking novel set in India that explores poverty, cruelty, human dignity, and the remarkable ability to endure even the harshest circumstances.

A Fine Balance Book Review: Hope and Despair in Rohinton Mistry’s Novel
In this review of A Fine Balance by Rohinton Mistry, Jim Tune explores a powerful novel about poverty, human dignity, cruelty, and resilience in India. Set in 1975, the story follows four strangers struggling through economic upheaval. Tune reflects on the novel’s heartbreaking portrayal of suffering and its remarkable depiction of human endurance.
- The novel follows four strangers whose lives are transformed by poverty and economic upheaval in India.
- Mistry explores the delicate balance between mercy and cruelty, hope and despair.
- Tune praises the novel’s powerful storytelling and its portrayal of human dignity and endurance.
A Fine Balance
Rohinton Mistry
St. Louis: Turtleback, 2001
I have given copies of A Fine Balance by Rohinton Mistry to more of my reading friends than possibly any other book I have read. All the cruelty and corruption, dignity and heroism of India is startlingly captured and made real to the reader. Set in 1975 in an unnamed city by the sea in India, this eye-opening novel looks at the lives of four strangers who have fallen, almost instantly, from a middle-class lifestyle to the ranks of the poor due to sudden economic upheaval.
These four strangers—a single woman on her own, a college student, and an uncle and his nephew struggling with poverty in a big city—have little in common, except for a resilient ability to find hope and escape their lot in life. At times you will soar with exhilaration as you share the hopes and dreams of the protagonists, actually believing with them that escape to a better life is possible. But it is a fine balance between mercy and cruelty, hope and despair. I warn you in advance this book may cause your heart to break.
Balancing Hope and Despair
Does the author succeed in balancing hope and despair? I am not certain that was his goal. With its anything-but-sentimental ending, I found this line from one of the characters hit close to home: “Losing, and losing again, it is the very basis of the life process, till all we are left with is the bare essence of human existence.”
On the encouraging side, this book will remind you of the human ability to endure—even to act heroically—in the midst of cruel circumstances. Although it is bleak, I found it hopeful too. It left me unsettled, which is not entirely a bad thing for a book to do. A true work of genius by a storytelling master!
Jim Tune is senior minister of Churchill Meadows Christian Church in Toronto, Canada. He is founder and director of Impact Canada, a national church planting organization, and serves as a contributing editor for CHRISTIAN STANDARD.
For 160 years Christian Standard has served the churches of the Restoration Movement. Your gift keeps articles like this one free for every church leader.
Keep reading
More in Reviews
From the archive
Christian Standard has covered this since 1866.












