A Difficult Standard, a Tricky Balance
Mark A. Taylor reflects on religious liberty, same-sex marriage, and conflicts of conscience, challenging Christians to uphold their convictions while treating others with dignity and speaking the truth in love.

Religious Liberty and Same-Sex Marriage: Speaking the Truth in Love
Religious liberty and same-sex marriage are at the center of this editorial by Mark A. Taylor. Responding to comments from Pope Francis and reported disputes involving business owners and public officials, Taylor considers the tension between religious convictions and the dignity of others. He challenges Christians to demonstrate the love of Jesus while remaining faithful to their understanding of Scripture.
- Pope Francis’s comments prompt a discussion about balancing moral teachings with the church’s broader message.
- Reported conflicts involving wedding services and public officials raise questions about religious liberty and conscience.
- The author urges Christians to combine respect and compassion for others with the responsibility to speak what they believe is true.
The September 20 issue of The Wall Street Journal quoted from a 12,000-word interview Pope Francis had given to the Italian Jesuit journal Civiltà Cattolica. “We cannot insist only on issues related to abortion, gay marriage, and the use of contraceptive methods,” he said. While affirming that the teachings of the church are clear about these matters, he added, “It is not necessary to talk about these issues all the time. We have to find a new balance; otherwise even the moral edifice of the church is likely to fall like a house of cards.”
While many Evangelicals would agree that the church’s message must be broader than sexual prohibitions, it appears that another “house of cards,” religious liberty in the U.S., has already started to collapse.
Religious Liberty and Same-Sex Marriage: Conflicts of Conscience
Mollie Ziegler Hemingway, also in the September 20 Journal, chronicled a spate of new actions against small business owners because they refused to violate their conscience by offering their services to gay wedding celebrations. Examples included a florist in Richland, Washington, a bakery in Gresham, Oregon, and a photographer in New Mexico. Meanwhile a host of civic officials have resigned their posts rather than process documents for same-sex weddings. Hemingway mentioned county recorders, magistrates, and judges in Iowa; justices of the peace in Massachusetts; and town clerks in New York. Many of these were told “refusing to perform services for same-sex couples will result in criminal prosecutions for misdemeanors or other sanctions.” And so, because of their deeply held religious beliefs about marriage, these civil servants just quit.
Most chilling in her column was the quote Hemingway included from legal scholar and gay-rights activist Chai Feldblum. In 2006, long before President Obama appointed him to the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, Feldblum said this:
There can be a conflict between religious liberty and sexual liberty, but in almost all cases the sexual liberty should win because that’s the only way the dignity of gay people can be affirmed in any realistic manner.
Speaking the Truth in Love
But Christians follow the One who always affirmed the dignity of even the vilest sinner before him. It’s a tragedy when homosexuals don’t feel that respect from Christians today. And now we have an even more complicated problem: How do we demonstrate the love of Jesus while also resisting the destruction of our country’s religious liberty?
We may feel the only way to do one is to ignore the other. But love does not force us to deny what we believe to be true, that the Scripture forbids same-sex practice. (The pope, by the way, has not denied that he believes this too.) We may encourage the church to be a place where homosexuals find a listening ear instead of a condemning stare. But this needn’t force us to seal our lips.
“Go and sin no more,” Jesus told the condemned adulteress, setting the stage for the goal his apostle would later set: “Speaking the truth in love.” It’s a difficult standard and a tricky balance, but never more needed as we navigate the waters of today’s emotional debates about gay lifestyles and gay rights.
For 160 years Christian Standard has served the churches of the Restoration Movement. Your gift keeps articles like this one free for every church leader.
Keep reading
More in Culture & Public Square
From the archive
Christian Standard has covered this since 1866.












