A July 4th Message from 1960
In this 1960 Independence Day editorial, Edwin Hayden explores the cost of freedom, the responsibilities of liberty, and Joshua's call to choose whom we will serve.

Christian Freedom and Responsibility: Which Kind of Freedom?
Christian freedom and responsibility are central themes in Edwin Hayden’s 1960 Independence Day editorial. Hayden contrasts freedom from cost with freedom from constraint, arguing that meaningful liberty requires sacrifice rather than guaranteed comfort. Drawing on Joshua 24:15, he concludes that the deepest freedom comes through choosing whom to serve.
- Freedom from cost and freedom from constraint are different ideals that can conflict with one another.
- Hayden presents the American founders’ willingness to sacrifice comfort and security as an example of choosing liberty.
- Joshua 24:15 provides the editorial’s spiritual conclusion: true freedom is found in willingly serving the Lord.
Here is an Independence Day editorial by Edwin Hayden from 1960 . . . 94 years after the founding of our magazine and 184 years after the founding of our nation.
Which Kind of Freedom?
An Editorial
July 2, 1960; p. 2
About to talk to a group of school children on the subject of freedom, the preacher asked his young hearers to define the word free. First offered was this: “Like getting into the show without paying.”
Free—“without cost”—has been lifted from an obscure and incidental place among the definitions of freedom so that it becomes a serious competitor to the basic free—“without constraint.” Giveaways and handouts are perennially popular. Wishful thinking keeps the fiction of something-for-nothing alive in the face of facts to the contrary, and the advocates of “security” reign as though pensions and price supports came out of thin air.
People learn slowly, if at all, that neither kind of freedom—relief from cost or relief from constraint—is ever absolute, and that the two make war against each other.
Complete security—the state of having all things provided by someone else—is available only to infants, slaves, and prisoners. Since men cannot be babes forever, they approach one of the other conditions as they seek to avoid their portion of the world’s toil, and hardship, and thinking, and sacrifice, and suffering. He who would enjoy the fullest measure of manly and Christian self-determination must be prepared to sacrifice much of social and economic comfort and security, but having done so, he will testify . . . that it was abundantly worth the cost.
July 4 memorializes a day when an infant nation chose the kind of freedom it would have. The men who put their names to the Declaration of Independence were not expecting freedom from want or freedom from fear. Their land was yielding its riches reluctantly, and they saw the shadow of the gallows on the document they signed. Dignity and humanity, not comfort and security, was their goal. They chose well, as history has testified.
“Choose you this day whom ye will serve!” Joshua’s challenge to Israel (Joshua 24:15) describes the pattern of human liberty. To be without a master is impossible, and the very attempt to throw off all controls will bring one into the most abject slavery to self and the whims of any given moment. One can and must, however, choose his master, and when that choice is made because of love, and when service rendered springs from affectionate devotion, the servant is then most truly free. The Christian will join with Joshua in his vow: “As for me and my house, we will serve the Lord!”
A Historical Note on Independence Day in Christian Standard
Now, a quick note that might be of some interest: The July 1, 1876, edition of Christian Standard carried nothing about our nation’s independence and/or freedom, though July 4 that year was our nation’s 100th birthday. Folks who were around in 1976 for our nation’s year-long bicentennial celebration will no doubt find that hard to believe.
—Jim Nieman, managing editor, Christian Standard
For 160 years Christian Standard has served the churches of the Restoration Movement. Your gift keeps articles like this one free for every church leader.
Keep reading
More in Culture & Public Square
From the archive
Christian Standard has covered this since 1866.











