Mary, Most Perplexed
Mary's bewilderment at the angel's announcement offers a surprising Christmas lesson. Jim Tune explores how doubt and uncertainty can expose our illusions of control, deepen dependence on God, and cultivate compassion.

Perplexity and Faith at Christmas: Learning from Mary’s Doubts
Perplexity and faith at Christmas meet in the story of Mary, who was bewildered by the angel’s announcement yet remained willing to serve God. Jim Tune reflects on how confusion and doubt can be part of an authentic spiritual life. He explores how God can use perplexity to challenge self-sufficiency, deepen dependence on him, and cultivate compassion for others.
- Mary’s perplexity is openly acknowledged in Scripture, showing that bewilderment does not necessarily mean spiritual weakness.
- Christians may struggle to admit doubts and weaknesses when they confuse spiritual aspirations with personal achievements.
- God can use uncertainty to humble us, deepen our dependence on him, and increase compassion for others.
Perplexity in the Christmas story
The Christmas story helps me appreciate perplexity. The Bible reminds me that God does some of his best work with people who are truly and seriously confused. Abraham and Sarah were perplexed about God’s promise. Elijah, even after a great victory, battles doubt and depression in the desert while fleeing the fury of a queen named Jezebel. And then there’s Mary.
In the weeks leading up to Christmas we will hear the story of Mary and her incredible dialogue with an angel. The Bible records that Mary “was much perplexed by his words and pondered what sort of greeting this might be” (Luke 1:29, New Revised Standard Version). Mary seems remarkably restrained in how she describes her emotional state and in what she commits to. Having given herself up in service to God, she says, “Let it be with me according to your word” (v. 38).
Mary doesn’t deny her doubts. The Gospel refuses to downplay the fact that she is perplexed, and that Christ’s conception is downright bewildering, even to Jesus’ mother. I think this is a freeing truth. It’s OK to doubt. Perplexity happens.
Perplexity, doubt, and authenticity
I read a fascinating observation about religion and a personality test called the MMPI (Minnesota Multiphasic Personality Inventory). The MMPI has a scale designed to detect false answers. Research indicates religious people tend to give more false answers than nonreligious people, and the more conservative a person’s religion, the more false answers he or she tends to give. Psychologists suggest this is because those of us inside a strong faith tradition tend to confuse our aspirations with our achievements. Religious people have a difficult time admitting their sin, struggles, and weaknesses. Perhaps they feel their doubts will disqualify them in the eyes of others.
It might be possible, dear reader, that you, like I, struggle with authenticity. We like our Christian brothers and sisters to be “together.” And if they aren’t together, they had best pull it together. Consequently, we are afraid to be truly known.
For many, perplexity is a sure sign of spiritual weakness—but Mary was anything but weak! God can use moments of bewilderment to destroy our illusions of control and self-sufficiency and to remind us of our utter dependence on him. He uses our times of perplexity to humble us and shape us into people who are poor in spirit. Being poor in spirit is the greatest of gifts. And it is more likely to be found in our bewilderment than in a stocking or under the tree.
When I don’t have it together or understand the circumstances I find myself in, I tend to become more compassionate toward those who are struggling. After all, if the mother of Jesus was perplexed, you can be too.
For 160 years Christian Standard has served the churches of the Restoration Movement. Your gift keeps articles like this one free for every church leader.
Keep reading
More in Discipleship & Spiritual Formation
From the archive
Christian Standard has covered this since 1866.











