How to Lead a Great Discussion
Michael C. Mack shares two lessons from Jim Lehrer on leading better small group discussions: keep the focus on participants and prepare well enough to listen rather than simply ask questions.

Small Group Discussion Listening Skills: Two Lessons for Leaders
Small group discussion listening skills help leaders create conversations centered on participants rather than themselves. Michael C. Mack draws on advice from Jim Lehrer to explain why effective leaders must keep the focus on group members and prepare well enough to listen. His examples show how attentiveness can strengthen discussions in small groups and classes.
- Effective group leaders keep attention on participants rather than themselves.
- Thoughtful preparation allows leaders to relax, listen, and respond to the discussion.
- Listening carefully is more important than simply asking the next prepared question.
Several years ago Jim Lehrer was interviewed about what it takes to moderate a political debate. Several of his techniques are also applicable to teachers and small group leaders.
1. The Focus Must Be on the Participants, Not the Moderator
Some moderators are better at this than others. It’s a learned skill, Lehrer said, not an innate ability. Group leaders and teachers must learn to keep the focus on the participants, not themselves. The leader’s job is not to teach a lesson, where everyone’s attention is on him or her, but to facilitate (or moderate) a discussion in which participants hear from God as they share with one another. How does a good leader facilitate this? Lehrer’s second comment is helpful.
2. A Moderator Must Prepare in Such a Way That He Is Relaxed Enough to Listen
Anyone can write and ask great questions, Lehrer said, but you prepare so that you can be relaxed enough to really listen. Lehrer shared a story from the 1960s about interviewing a U.S. senator. The interview went like this:
Lehrer: “Should we sell more grain to Cuba?”
Senator: “Yes, Jim, I think we should sell more grain to Cuba. But first, we should bomb Havana.”
Lehrer: “What kind of grain, Senator?”
This happens in groups and classes as well. A leader asks a question from the study guide, and a great discussion follows. Meanwhile, the leader is looking down at his book. As the discussion slows down, the leader looks up and asks the next question, which was already answered during the previous discussion. The leader wasn’t listening. He was thinking about his or her next question.
Listening is one of the most important skills a group leader or teacher must learn. As a shepherd leader, focus on the people in the group and prepare in such a way that you can relax enough to listen and join in the discussion.
For 160 years Christian Standard has served the churches of the Restoration Movement. Your gift keeps articles like this one free for every church leader.
Keep reading
More in Church Leadership
From the archive
Christian Standard has covered this since 1866.












