Beyond the Ballot Box
Should Christians place their hope in election results? Mark A. Taylor reflects on Jennifer Johnson's challenge to engage in politics while remembering that changing hearts matters more than changing laws.

Christian Convictions and Elections: Where Should We Place Our Hope?
As Christians participate in elections, they must consider whether political victories can accomplish the deeper transformation they desire. Drawing on Jennifer Johnson’s message at the International Conference on Missions, Mark A. Taylor reflects on the difference between changing laws and changing hearts. He encourages believers to participate in civic life without placing their ultimate hope in election outcomes.
- Christians can vote and engage in public debates while remembering that their primary calling extends beyond politics.
- Jennifer Johnson emphasizes that changing hearts and lives matters more than winning elections or changing laws.
- Regardless of election results, believers can demonstrate the transforming power of their convictions through their lives.
Once again it’s Election Day in America, and as Christians march to the polls to express their convictions, it’s time to remind ourselves why we go and what we hope to accomplish.
Do we expect to change America through the ballot box? As candidates bob and weave to attract the Evangelical vote ahead of caucuses, primaries, and the presidential election a full year from now, how much hope are we hanging on their positions and pronouncements?
Changing Hearts Instead of Winning Elections
Jennifer Johnson offered her answer in her message Saturday morning at the International Conference on Missions (ICOM) in Richmond, Virginia.
“Our job is to win souls, not to win elections; our job is to change lives, not to change laws,” she said. “This doesn’t mean we don’t have convictions, but it might mean we have to change how we express them.”
She quoted New York Times columnist Ross Douthat: “Himself a believer, he says the more we focus on fighting a few morality wars in politics, the more we are a special interest group with nothing transcendent to offer anyone.”
I well remember decades ago hearing Focus on the Family’s James Dobson express frustration because Christians were absent from public debates and congressional hearings about issues where Christians have profound convictions. Since then the Moral Majority has arisen and waned, the Reagan era has come and gone. Christian ethics are not the cultural norm in government or entertainment, and Christians knew—even before Jim Tune made “Away Team” the theme of this year’s ICOM—that we’d lost home field advantage in the public square.
Johnson responds, “We need to let go of this idea that the government of the United States is going to reflect the values of the Bible. The first-century church lived in an environment where that was absolutely not true.”
While acknowledging that voting, letter writing, even campaigning, or protesting are our right if not our responsibility, she said, “We can participate, but that’s not where our hope should be.”
Living Beyond the Ballot Box
Today I will vote against legalizing marijuana in Ohio where I live. I will do so because I believe legalized marijuana use will add to family brokenness, traffic tragedies, and other kinds of heartbreak in the city where I live. I will cast my vote out of my Christian conviction about how the outcome of this election could damage the fabric of my community.
But if marijuana use becomes legal in my state, or if the next president of my country turns out to be an anti-Christian scoundrel, I will try to remember Johnson’s words and refrain from wringing my hands. “Even the best laws change only behavior,” she said Saturday. “But we are in the business of changing hearts.”
Regardless of how this election, or any election turns out, I must redouble my efforts to open my heart to God and demonstrate to others how and why that change is making a difference way beyond the ballot box.
Go to www.catapes.com to order an audio or video recording of Jennifer Johnson’s message, along with the whole session, including a challenge from Caleb Kaltenbach and a testimony by Caleb Lucas. Their messages were delivered Saturday morning, October 31, 2015, at ICOM.
For 160 years Christian Standard has served the churches of the Restoration Movement. Your gift keeps articles like this one free for every church leader.
Keep reading
More in Culture & Public Square
From the archive
Christian Standard has covered this since 1866.












