How to Respond to the Trend of ‘Churchless Christians’
What does it mean when 62 percent of churchless Americans identify as Christians? Michael C. Mack explores Barna Group findings and considers how churches can respond through stronger discipleship and renewed engagement.

Churchless Americans and Christianity: What the Survey Findings Mean for Churches
Churchless Americans and Christianity are the focus of Michael C. Mack’s examination of Barna Group survey findings. The article reports that 62 percent of churchless Americans considered themselves Christians and explores how churches might respond. Perspectives from Mike Shannon, James Emery White, and Ed Stetzer emphasize biblical commitment, discipleship, and renewed engagement.
- A Barna Group survey reported that 62 percent of churchless Americans considered themselves Christians.
- Church leaders and researchers offer different perspectives on religious affiliation and changing patterns of participation.
- The article encourages churches to emphasize biblical commitment, mature discipleship, and gospel engagement.
According to a Barna Group survey, the majority (62 percent) of churchless Americans consider themselves Christians. “Most of the churchless in America—contrary to what one might believe—do not disdain Christianity nor desire to belittle it or tear it down,” says the report.
This graph provides a more detailed breakdown:
Churchless Americans and Christianity: Understanding the Findings
How can churches make sense of these surprising findings, and more importantly, what can churches do in response to them?
“I think a dissatisfaction with the institutional church is significantly responsible for the result,” says Mike Shannon, professor at Cincinnati (Ohio) Christian University.
In The Rise of the Nones: Understanding and Reaching the Religiously Unaffiliated (Baker, 2014), James Emery White says that 20 percent of Americans check the box labeled “none” in regard to their religious affiliation. And most churches, says White, are doing nothing to reach this fastest-growing religious group.
Ed Stetzer, executive director at LifeWay Research, says this phenomenon is not a justification for Christian leaders to panic. These findings don’t mean the church is dying, but that it’s transitioning. “I believe this current cultural shift is bringing clarity that will assist in defining who we are as Christians, and that is a good thing in some ways,” Stetzer says. “Christianity is represented by people who live for Christ, not check ‘Christian’ on a survey form.” (See Stetzer’s article, “The State of the Church in America: Hint: It’s Not Dying,” at ChristianityToday.com,)
How Churches Can Respond
How can churches respond in light of this trend? “I think churches need to get back to teaching from the Bible about lordship and commitment,” says Shannon. “It might cost us a few numbers at first, but the disciples would be more mature and eventually make a greater impact.”
As Christians and churches find themselves more and more on the margins of society, points out Stetzer, it’s an opportunity for us to count the cost and move “into the mission field as agents of gospel transformation.” It’s time for Christians to regroup and reengage.
For 160 years Christian Standard has served the churches of the Restoration Movement. Your gift keeps articles like this one free for every church leader.
Keep reading
More in Church & Ministry
From the archive
Christian Standard has covered this since 1866.












