TRANSITIONS: Facing the Facts of Transition
Russell Crabtree, Holy Cow Consulting, The Elephant in the Boardroom, pastoral transitions, succession planning, Disciples of Christ, Episcopal Church, Columbus Ohio,

Succession planning for pastoral transitions
Russell Crabtree says many churches avoid thinking about leadership transitions until they’re forced into a crisis. He argues that planning for pastoral succession is not unspiritual, but a Spirit-guided process that helps churches navigate inevitable change. Without a plan, congregations can struggle deeply when a longtime preacher leaves.
- Many churches don’t build structures that encourage transition planning.
- Highly structured traditions may handle leadership change more smoothly.
- Prayerful, straightforward planning can prevent crisis-driven decisions.
Planning for leadership transitions
If there’s one organization that should realize this life doesn’t last forever, it ought to be the church, says Russell Crabtree.
But you wouldn’t know it from churches’ lack of planning, especially for leadership transitions.
“We live in absolute denial of the fact that the tenure of our leaders is going to come to an end,” said Crabtree, co-author of The Elephant in the Boardroom: Speaking the Unspoken About Pastoral Transitions.
“We really don’t have the structures that encourage this kind of thinking. We have a mind-set about the clergy that they are like parental figures. Well, if you’re family you don’t sit around and say how are we going to get a new dad when this one is gone.”
Crabtree, who grew up in a Disciples of Christ church, runs Holy Cow Consulting in Columbus, Ohio. The company conducts diagnostics of church health and helps prepare succession plans.
He said as baby boomers age, many religious groups are facing the loss of longtime leaders. For example, 30 percent of Episcopalian priests are slated to retire in the next five years.
In perhaps a sobering observation for independent churches, he says highly structured, ritualistic groups are best equipped to handle a change in leadership. Catholics, for instance, have grown accustomed to seeing longtime priests replaced quickly.
In contrast, churches with looser structures and no succession plan often experience devastating consequences when a longtime preacher leaves.
“So much is built around that leader that when they go it’s like a death, and people need a year to get over it.”
Crabtree cautioned that transition plans are not “one-size-fits-all.” But he also rejected the notion that such planning is somehow unspiritual.
In fact the Spirit’s role is critically important when believers gather to prayerfully seek God’s will for their church’s future and what kind of leader they need to best impact the world, Crabtree said.
“I think overall we’re going to be better off as a church if we deal with this in a straightforward manner rather than in a crisis mode.”
For 160 years Christian Standard has served the churches of the Restoration Movement. Your gift keeps articles like this one free for every church leader.
Keep reading
More in Church Leadership
From the archive
Christian Standard has covered this since 1866.











