Ten Ways to Stifle Discussion in Your Group or Class
Want to ruin a Bible study discussion? Michael C. Mack humorously reveals 10 leadership mistakes that silence participation, discourage conversation, and turn meaningful group study into a one-person performance.

10 Ways to Stifle Bible Study Discussion
What makes a Bible study discussion ineffective? Through 10 tongue-in-cheek examples, Michael C. Mack highlights leadership habits that can discourage participation, silence honest conversation, and undermine meaningful group interaction. From dominating the discussion to insisting on complete control, these examples offer a humorous look at what Bible study leaders should avoid.
- Overly controlling leadership can discourage meaningful group participation.
- Listening, patience, and openness are important to productive Bible study discussions.
- Effective discussion involves more than delivering information or asking questions.
10 Ways to Stifle Bible Study Discussion
1. Use impressive, big words like regeneration, justification, and eschatology as much as possible.
2. Interject names such as Polycarp, Dietrich Bonhoeffer and, yes, Rick Warren and Max Lucado.
3. Be serious all the time. Since you are studying God’s Holy Word, there is no time for fun or frivolity!
4. Don’t allow people to share their feelings. Focus on facts. Feelings have no place in Bible study.
5. Do most of the talking. Study diligently and then share everything you learned about your topic. This is what it means to teach.
6. If no one responds to one of your questions within five seconds, answer it yourself and move on to the next question.
7. When participants answer incorrectly (because there is always one correct response), be sure to shame, correct, and dismiss them. (Corollary: Remember that, as the leader, you are always right.)
8. Ask 10 or more discussion questions (the more the better). Allow only one response per question, and limit responses to 20 seconds.
9. Keep your eyes on your Bible and study guide. Read questions and commentary as much as possible. After asking a question, look down at your books to see what the next question is.
10. Be in complete control of the discussion. Don’t allow any conversation that is not part of your own meeting agenda. You must set stringent boundaries with group members.
For 160 years Christian Standard has served the churches of the Restoration Movement. Your gift keeps articles like this one free for every church leader.
Keep reading
More in Church & Ministry
From the archive
Christian Standard has covered this since 1866.













I have done the exact opposite of #1, #2, #5, and parts of #7, #9, and #10. The effect has been that my class has grown! Both Sunday school and my book club that meets every month! It’s crazy. How do you explain this phenomenon, especially since so many participate in discussion and are learning?