The Myth of the Supreme Leader
What can Kim Jong-il's legendary golf achievements teach Christian leaders? Jim Tune explores the danger of manufactured perfection and why authentic leadership begins by acknowledging our humanity and following the example of Jesus.

Christian Leadership Authenticity: The Myth of the Perfect Leader
Christian leadership authenticity means rejecting the pressure to appear perfect. The exaggerated achievements attributed to North Korea’s Kim Jong-il illustrate the dangers of carefully manufactured leadership images. Jim Tune contrasts these claims with the genuine perfection and humanity of Jesus Christ, challenging Christian leaders to reject image management and lead with integrity.
- Exaggerated leadership images can replace reality with a carefully maintained illusion.
- Jesus was fully divine yet experienced ordinary human needs, including hunger, thirst, and exhaustion.
- Christian leaders should embrace their humanity rather than cultivate an appearance of perfection.
In 2007 a Southern California woman named Jacqueline Gagne claimed she made 16 holes in one—10 of them in less than a four-month period. A statistician determined the odds of that occurring to be 12 septillion to 1.
As far-fetched as that sounds, Gagne holds nothing on Kim Jong-il, the former “Supreme Leader” of North Korea. During his reign as the unchallenged leader of the secretive nation, Kim, according to official North Korean state media reports, routinely shot three or four holes in one per round of golf.
The Myth of the Supreme Leader
But Kim’s greatest feat occurred the very first day he picked up a club. According to witnesses, the “Dear Leader” played his best round ever—and the best of all time—at the grand opening of the Pongyang Golf Complex, which contains North Korea’s only 18-hole golf course.
Kim shot a 38-under-par round of 34 at Pyongyang. Security guards at the scene verified that the score included an amazing 11 aces. Of course, the event was dutifully reported to the North Korean masses by the state news agency.
In Jacqueline Gagne’s case, Golf Digest writer Dave Kindred interviewed some of her golfing partners. None of them claimed she was faking any of the holes in one, though Kindred couldn’t find a single witness who saw any of Gagne’s tee shots actually disappear into a hole. Kim, at least, had 17 credible bodyguards on hand to testify to his achievement!
In a totalitarian regime, the leader’s image must always be exaggerated. The sacred public image of the “Supreme Leader” is of utmost importance; it must be constantly groomed, managed, and photoshopped. In North Korea, national lore holds that the nation’s leader never needed to go to the bathroom. His perfect 5-foot-2-inch body functioned so efficiently that it wasn’t necessary.
Christian Leaders and the Humanity of Jesus
But we worship someone who truly was perfect. Yet his body functioned like every man’s. This becomes clear, for example, when we read John 4. The Gospel writer tells us Jesus was tired, hungry, and thirsty. Jesus was “the exact representation of his being” (Hebrews 1:3). Jesus was God, but Jesus also was human. Jesus—truly our divine leader—became hungry, lonely, tired, and thirsty. We disregard either his humanity or his divinity to our peril.
Christian leaders can be tempted to look way more like Kim Jong-il than Jesus Christ. We are tempted to modify, manage, and inflate our persona in order to look perfect and lead perfectly. But are we really to be less human than Jesus himself was?
Like Jesus, we are fully human. Unlike Jesus, we are not fully divine. Yet God loves working through us. As leaders, when we give in to image management, it is no longer we who are leading, but a lie about us that is leading.
For 160 years Christian Standard has served the churches of the Restoration Movement. Your gift keeps articles like this one free for every church leader.
Keep reading
More in Church Leadership
From the archive
Christian Standard has covered this since 1866.











