Church Leadership

Gut Check

Can you trust your leadership instincts? Eddie Lowen shares humorous lessons from his early ministry mistakes and offers five practical ways to seek wisdom, evaluate decisions, and lead with greater humility.

trusting your instincts
In brief

Trusting Your Instincts: Five Lessons for Wise Leadership Decisions

Good leadership requires more than trusting your gut. Eddie Lowen shares lessons from his early ministry mistakes and offers five practical ways to evaluate instincts, seek wise counsel, and make decisions that stand the test of time.

  • Recognize that confidence in your instincts does not always mean your judgment is reliable.
  • Seek input, evaluate past decisions, and look for confirmation when the stakes are high.
  • Draw wisdom from Scripture and consider how today’s decisions will affect your future.

Pixar’s movie Inside Out is clever. It’s about an 11-year-old girl whose family moves from Minnesota to San Francisco. The genius of the film is its vivid and humorous portrayal of the memories, thoughts, and emotions that compete to control the girl’s behavior.

If I had to select one word to capture all three of those elements—memory, thought, and emotion—I’d choose the word instinct.

How good are your instincts? Let me guess: pretty good. As you read my question, you thought, I trust my gut. My instincts are above average.

10_Lowen-gut_JNThat’s the problem. Everyone thinks his or her instincts are better than average. I’m not a statistician, but I’m pretty sure it can’t work that way, mathematically! Remember Garrison Keillor’s fictional town, Lake Wobegon, where “all the children are above average”?

Psychologists call this illusory superiority. The Bible calls it pride. One of the distinctive characteristics of the human race is that we trust our instincts way too much. In light of our record (human history), you would think “gut trusting” would be considered foolish.

But then we hear of someone who trusted his or her instincts and won a war, or saved a child, or discovered a cure, or invented an amazing technology. So, it appears to work both ways. Should we trust our instincts or not?

Hard Lessons

My earliest attempts at employing my own ministry instincts were painful. On my very first weekend as a church staff member, I made three bad calls. The good news is I dispersed my ineptitude across several areas of ministry, which may have saved the church.

Error 1: While directing games at a church picnic, I led a game in which the students were challenged to fish pieces of candy out of plate full of syrup with their tongues. It was disastrous on several levels. Girls got syrup on their hair, as their parents watched. Students placed their noses and tongues in syrup where other students had placed their noses and tongues, as their parents watched. Flies and bees gathered to enjoy the syrup, including the syrup on the students. Did I mention that parents were watching?

Error 2: I offered a single mother a ride to the church picnic. Both of us were single, so it wasn’t a problem that we were in a car together. The problem was that it was the early 1980s (before child safety laws) and she decided to nurse the baby. I somehow found a route to the park using all left turns.

Error 3: After leading a hymn that Sunday in church, I offered some theological commentary on the song. It disrupted the flow of our worship gathering. It added several minutes to the service. It was stuffy and stupid.

Other than those three blunders, my first weekend on a church staff was a huge success! My instincts let me down in a big way. Here’s some guidance for evaluating your own.

Five Ways to Evaluate Your Leadership Instincts

• The younger you are, the sooner you should ask for input.

When I was a young leader, I was often too eager to prove I didn’t need guidance. I now understand I would have earned greater respect if I had been less threatened by help.

What would have happened if I had called Rob Raynor, a friend and one of the finest student pastors of that era, who was a few miles away at a sister church? He would have told me the syrup game was a bad idea. He would have suggested I take someone with me to pick up the single mom. Rob was a great worship leader, too, so he would have nixed my theological yapping, if I had asked for his input.

Young leaders: rarely will you disappoint a supervisor by asking a question. In fact, asking peers and subordinates will help, too.

• Test the quality of your instincts when everything is not on the line.

There is such a thing as leadership. I’m convinced God distributes the gift of leadership because there are times when someone needs to know what to do, even if he doesn’t know how he knows.

If you’re gifted to lead, there will be moments when you just know that you know. I’m not talking about times when insecurity or ego is driving you to be right. I’m speaking of moments when your heart is humble, but an answer is crystal clear.

If you have that gift, be careful about exercising it when everything is on the line. If a mistake would damage a lot of people or require years of recovery, look for confirmation.

• Assess your instinctive moves from the past.

When you review the gut-level decisions you’ve made in the past, what do you see? What do others see? Disillusioned people? Confusion? Or, do you see people who are glad they followed you?

Not every good decision produces more growth and happy people, but over the course of time, your instincts will be proven either reliable or questionable. The people around you will normally tell you which it is.

By the way, most people have areas of strength in which they tend to make excellent calls, even though they show weakness in other areas. You might need to go with your gut in one realm, while leaning on other people’s instincts in another. We all have a wheelhouse and an outhouse.

• What does the Bible teach?

Several years ago, I would have included this one just out of principle. But years of ministry are reteaching me that the Bible is an unending source of wisdom. Experience is valuable. Giftedness makes a huge difference, but drawing insight from the Bible will enrich everyone around you. Colossians 3:16 says, “Let the message of Christ dwell among you richly.”

• What will the future me want to be able to say about this decision?

Solomon begged his son to chase what is wise, rather than what was pleasing at the moment. I frequently tell my young adult son, “Make decisions that your 30-year-old self and your 40-year-old self will congratulate you for making. Make decisions that you wife will thank you for making.”

Weigh your decisions on future scales. In fact, when something has an immediate reward, be skeptical. Be suspicious. We often hear people cite the brevity of life for perspective. That’s biblical thinking. But if God gives you two more years, or 10 more years, or 20 more years, what do you want the future to look like? Lay the foundation for that vision now. Ask the future you what to do.

Eddie Lowen serves as lead minister with West Side Christian Church in Springfield, Illinois, and on Standard Publishing’s Publishing Committee.

Eddie Lowen
Author: Eddie Lowen

Sponsored

Renew University
About the author

Eddie Lowen

Eddie Lowen has written 36 articles for Christian Standard.

More from Eddie Lowen →
Christian Standard is reader-supported

For 160 years Christian Standard has served the churches of the Restoration Movement. Your gift keeps articles like this one free for every church leader.

Sponsored

IDES INTERNATIONAL DISASTER EMERGENCY SERVICE ides Christian Standard

Keep reading

More in Church Leadership

From the archive

Christian Standard has covered this since 1866.

Subscribe
Notify of
1 Comment
David Cole
11 years ago

Humans don’t have instincts. What the author is talking about is “intuition” and “common sense”. They are acquired by experience.

Get Online Access to Be Seen, Be Heard
A Two Hour Online Visibility Course for Churches

Be Seen Be Heard Online Course - Christian Standard

Learn how to turn the sermons you’re already preaching into searchable, shareable content that helps people discover and connect with your local church. Access Be Seen, Be Heard on demand with Wes Woodell and Trey Sheneman. A two hour course for preachers, church media and website teams, and anyone who wants to help their church reach more people online.

No, thank you.
Transactions are 100% secure.


No, thank you.
Help Keep Christian Standard Free & Accessible with a Tax Deductible Donation

We can do more together!

Every gift makes a difference!

No, thank you.
100% secure transactions - receipts provided.
Does Your Church Want to Support Christian Standard?

Would your church consider including support for Christian Standard in its annual missions budget? Your support would help us not only continue the 160-year legacy of this unifying ministry, but also expand the free resources, cooperative opportunities, and practical guidance we provide to strengthen churches in the U.S. and around the world.

We can do more together!

Every gift makes a difference!

No, thank you.
100% secure transactions - receipts provided.
1
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x