Church Leadership

The Secret-Driven Life

Why do pastors struggle to reveal their true selves? Jim Tune explores pastoral vulnerability, the hidden cost of shame and secrecy, and the courage required to live authentically in God's grace.

pastoral vulnerability
In brief

Pastoral Vulnerability: The Courage to Be Real

Pastoral vulnerability requires the courage to be honest about personal struggles, weaknesses, and the fear of rejection. Jim Tune reflects on the dangers of hiding behind a carefully maintained public image and the freedom that comes from embracing authenticity and God’s grace.

  • Pastors often face expectations that make honesty and vulnerability difficult.
  • Secrecy and shame can create a damaging divide between a pastor’s public and private life.
  • Embracing vulnerability means risking rejection while discovering the freedom of living authentically.

(This column was first posted November 5, 2014.)

To be real is to risk. I know many preachers who feel a deep reluctance (often well-founded) to reveal who they really are to those they lead. Henri Nouwen suggests that pastors are the least confessing people in the church. The expectations demanded of pastors in our Western culture are often unattainable, unsustainable, and soul-withering.

11_Tune_JN

I admit that I have sometimes allowed my own fear of vulnerability to push me into hiding. The trouble with life in the shadows is the double life it promotes in the shadow dweller. I find myself preaching God’s unconditional love but living under religion’s conditional love. I’ve discovered it is possible to preach free, yet live enslaved.

Other preachers struggle with this too. They ask, “Where can I truly be myself? If people know who I am, will they reject me? Do people love me as their pastor but not as a person?”

The Danger of Hiding Behind a Pastoral Image

When Dallas Willard speaks of “sin management,” he has this fear of authenticity in mind. For example, I’ve occasionally been guilty of sharing just enough of my brokenness to gain rapport and even admiration. I can even come across as somewhat heroic. But I am still withholding my darkest areas.

This is a dangerous posture to assume. Ministry becomes a show. The pastor must perform a tireless dance of careful role-playing to save face by never showing his whole self to others.

Shame thrives where silence and secrecy abound. While many are familiar with the purpose-driven life, Gordon MacDonald says pastors are at risk of leading the secret-driven life.

The apostle Paul was able to boast about his weaknesses. We prefer to cower for fear that all will be known about us. In The Road to Oz, the Tiger says something that rings true to some of my experiences: “Hush, Dorothy,” whispered the Tiger, “you’ll ruin my reputation if you are not more discreet. It isn’t what we are, but what folks think we are, that counts in this world.”

Choosing Vulnerability Over Shame and Secrecy

As I get older, I find that I am finally ready to accept who I am. Others may not. Others may decide they prefer the guy they thought I was, and thus desert me. Some prefer living in Oz. But that’s OK. I think the risk is worth it.

Thomas Keating says, “The spiritual journey is not a career or success story. It is a series of humiliations of the false self that become more and more profound.” I suspect that sooner or later the false self always gets revealed. When it does, the public unmasking can be ruinous. Worse still, the secret bearer has known only shame and secrecy instead of the life-giving grace of God.

Madeleine L’Engle said, “If we refuse to take the risk of being vulnerable, we are already half-dead.” I’ll take the risk.

Jim Tune
Author: Jim Tune

Sponsored

Logo_Renew.orgNetwork-05 2560x1340
About the author

Jim Tune

Jim Tune has written 127 articles for Christian Standard.

More from Jim Tune →
Christian Standard is reader-supported

For 160 years Christian Standard has served the churches of the Restoration Movement. Your gift keeps articles like this one free for every church leader.

Sponsored

Filament Bible1200x675

Keep reading

More in Church Leadership

From the archive

Christian Standard has covered this since 1866.

Subscribe
Notify of
4 Comments
Cheryl
12 years ago

Thanks for the authenticity in this piece.

12 years ago

This is why I look up to you. You are a real person, and not afraid to admit it. I pray we all find someone in the closest of inner circles to reveal our darkest secrets to… it is a heavy burden to carry alone.

Not to inflate your ego ;), but many could learn from your leadership. Thank you for this.

David Cole
11 years ago

“I find myself preaching God”™s unconditional love but living under religion”™s conditional love.”

You fail to understand covenant. All promises in God’s covenants were conditional on covenant keeping. The New Convent is no exception. No one receives eternal life without faith. Faith is intentional and a active participation in New Covenant righteousness. We are to live like Christ and participate in the ministry of reconciliation if we are to receive God’s loving eternal life. There is nothing “unconditional” about God’s promises, love or reception of his grace. It can’t be earned by our own righteousness but Christlike faith is required.

11 years ago

One of the advantages of being a planned and trained “tent maker” in the Christian tool box of opportunities, is the removal of the fear of loosing your family income to care and provide for wife, children et al. That frees you up to be more honest to the Word of God in the pulpit, in writing and in personal response to people. That leaves me with the struggle of my relationship to God and his Word as my main struggle with honesty and transparency as I deal with those in the church and those I am seeking to bring to the Lord.

Get Online Access to Be Seen, Be Heard
A Two Hour Online Visibility Course for Churches

Be Seen Be Heard Online Course - Christian Standard

Learn how to turn the sermons you’re already preaching into searchable, shareable content that helps people discover and connect with your local church. Access Be Seen, Be Heard on demand with Wes Woodell and Trey Sheneman. A two hour course for preachers, church media and website teams, and anyone who wants to help their church reach more people online.

No, thank you.
Transactions are 100% secure.


No, thank you.
Help Keep Christian Standard Free & Accessible with a Tax Deductible Donation

We can do more together!

Every gift makes a difference!

No, thank you.
100% secure transactions - receipts provided.
Does Your Church Want to Support Christian Standard?

Would your church consider including support for Christian Standard in its annual missions budget? Your support would help us not only continue the 160-year legacy of this unifying ministry, but also expand the free resources, cooperative opportunities, and practical guidance we provide to strengthen churches in the U.S. and around the world.

We can do more together!

Every gift makes a difference!

No, thank you.
100% secure transactions - receipts provided.
4
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x