Reading Again for the First Time
Mark A. Taylor explores how the curse of knowledge affects longtime Christians, challenging readers to rediscover the wonder of Scripture and communicate its message with greater understanding.

The Curse of Knowledge: Seeing the Bible with Fresh Eyes
The curse of knowledge can make it difficult for longtime Christians to recognize how unfamiliar the gospel may be to others. Mark A. Taylor draws on an observation from Dan Ariely to explore how religious familiarity can create barriers to understanding. He encourages believers to approach Scripture as though reading it for the first time and consider how its message speaks to people outside the church.
- People who know a subject well can forget what it feels like to encounter it for the first time.
- Longtime Christians may underestimate how unfamiliar biblical stories and Christian practices are to others.
- Reading Scripture with fresh curiosity can help believers better understand its message and communicate it to others.
“Do professors have to be boring?” Dan Ariely’s answer to the college student who asked that question offers insight for Christians as well as academics. I can imagine a secular neighbor or friend asking, “Do Christians have to be ‘churchy’?”
The student’s problem, posed to the Wall Street Journal advice columnist, was this: He had recently attended a lecture by a well-known professor and “was amazed and baffled” by the teacher’s inability to communicate even basic concepts in a compelling and understandable way. The student’s question, which got me to thinking about lifetime Christians like me: “How can experts be so bad at explaining ideas to others?”
Ariely’s answer was that experts have studied what they know for so long that they forget what it was like to approach the subject for the first time. “When we know something and know it well, it is hard for us to appreciate what other people understand. This problem is sometimes called ‘the curse of knowledge.'”
How the Curse of Knowledge Affects Christians
And so it is that many of us Christians have known the gospel story for so long that we take for granted its miracles and marvels. We’ve forgotten the lump in the throat and the quickening heartbeat that accompanied our first response to Christ. We no longer remember the constricting fear we felt before we learned how to find forgiveness for our failures. We’ve settled into the routine and respectability of our weekly church practices and have become isolated from the desperation or cynicism below the surface in many of our friends’ lives.
And we may not realize how little non-Christians know or understand about the biblical record. I think of my mother’s friend who asked her, “Have you read those stories in the Bible? Wow, if even half that stuff is true, that’s really something!” Or my next-door neighbor who said she always got confused trying to explain Christian holidays to her Buddhist Japanese husband. Her question: “Is Easter when you celebrate the birth or the death of Jesus?”
If you’re still looking for a New Year’s resolution, here’s one to try on for size: In your Bible reading this year, try to imagine you’re encountering each text for the very first time. What does it tell you about the God who inspired it? What does it offer and what does it demand of those who read it? What could it mean to the problems and questions common to everyone, especially those, unlike you, who have never encountered its truth before?
For 160 years Christian Standard has served the churches of the Restoration Movement. Your gift keeps articles like this one free for every church leader.
Keep reading
More in Christian Living
From the archive
Christian Standard has covered this since 1866.











