Still Painful
How should churches respond to people with same-sex attraction? Mark A. Taylor revisits Christian Standard's call to combine biblical conviction with compassion, listening, and a gracious spirit toward others.

Same-Sex Attraction and the Church: Responding with Grace and Truth
Same-sex attraction and the church remain subjects of difficult conversations about biblical conviction, compassion, and relationships. Mark A. Taylor revisits Christian Standard’s longstanding call for churches to respond compassionately to people with same-sex attraction while remaining faithful to their understanding of biblical teaching. Drawing on articles by Mark Moore, Ben Cachiaras, Vince Antonucci, and Robert Gagnon, he emphasizes the importance of combining conviction with genuine care.
- Churches should demonstrate compassion and sensitivity toward people with same-sex attraction.
- Christian Standard’s earlier articles emphasize speaking biblical truth with love rather than ostracizing people.
- Disagreement over homosexual practice should not prevent Christians from listening, building relationships, and showing grace.
All the news about conservative churches and their response to those with same-sex attraction reminded me of a post I wrote three years ago. That week I challenged the church to demonstrate both grace and truth as we discuss this difficult issue and reach out to those celebrating and seeking gay marriage.
Follow the links in the below post to even older posts, and you’ll see a constant message urging us to find ways to show gays that Jesus loves them.
Compassion Toward Those with Same-Sex Attraction
More than once in recent years, CHRISTIAN STANDARD has advocated for compassion toward homosexuals.
We published Mark Moore’s plea that those with same-sex attraction need not identify themselves as “gay” and the church should not ostracize them.
Before that we reprinted Ben Cachiaras’s advice to his church when the issue of same-sex marriage was before the Maryland state legislature. In a piece filled with calls for sensitivity toward gay couples, he wrote, “We must be extra careful about how we discuss this so we don’t give any reasons for Christians to be misunderstood as uncaring or hate-mongers.”
Long before gay marriage became such a hot button, we published Vince Antonucci’s description of how the church where he was preaching related to homosexuals in its community. He spoke of sharing “painful truth” about the Bible’s teaching on homosexual practice with “overwhelming love” toward those involved in homosexual practice. He ended with, “When will the ‘sinners’ of our society (including homosexuals) be drawn to us? When will ‘speaking the truth in love’ not be a cliché we talk about but a reality we live out?”
Same-Sex Attraction and the Church: Holding Biblical Conviction and Compassion Together
Antonucci’s questions still challenge us. Yet, given today’s constant drumbeat promoting acceptance of homosexual practice, it is good for Christians to remind themselves why they can’t. The careful and complete study by Dr. Robert Gagnon is an excellent help here.
Some words of caution: Notice Gagnon’s essay consistently and carefully uses the term homosexual practice, not homosexuality. We can condemn the act, but we must love the person. Many among us with same-sex attraction are already ashamed or afraid of their tendency. What they need from the church is a listening ear, a gracious spirit, and help to cope.
Gagnon’s essay is not intended as a weapon against such people but as a defense against falsehood. Every day another attractive, prominent, and persuasive advocate promotes what the Bible forbids. We must love and talk with such people. But we need not agree with them. Professor Gagnon’s work reminds us why.
For 160 years Christian Standard has served the churches of the Restoration Movement. Your gift keeps articles like this one free for every church leader.
Keep reading
More in Ethics & Moral Issues

Should Christian Organizations Use Non-Disclosure Agreements?

A FEMINIST ARGUES OUR CULTURE OF SEXUAL LIBERATION HARMS WOMEN AND MOSTLY SERVES PRIVILEGED MEN

AI Companions and Christian Faith: How the Church Should Respond to Artificial Intimacy
From the archive
Christian Standard has covered this since 1866.








