Annual Panic
Recruiting church volunteers doesn't have to mean annual panic. Mark A. Taylor shares practical insights from Susan Lawrence and Melissa Sandel on planning ahead, communicating vision, and helping volunteers find the right roles.

Recruiting Church Volunteers: Leadership, Planning, and Finding the Right Fit
Recruiting church volunteers requires more than filling empty positions. Drawing on a conversation with Susan Lawrence and Melissa Sandel, Mark A. Taylor explores how thoughtful planning, clear vision, and matching people with suitable roles can strengthen volunteer recruitment and help churches develop dependable teams.
- Plan volunteer recruitment throughout the year instead of relying on last-minute efforts to fill positions.
- Communicate the purpose behind each volunteer role and how it contributes to the church’s larger mission.
- Help people find roles that fit their abilities, then equip and care for them over time.
Every August and September, I was gripped by panic. As part-time education minister with a smaller church (now it’s mega), I was responsible to recruit Sunday school workers for every age level and to staff a fully graded program on Wednesday nights. When kids choirs took a break on Sunday evenings (we had Sunday-night church back in those days), my job was to create and find workers for kids’ classes then too.
In a church of a few hundred, that was a lot of volunteers, and we never seemed to have quite enough.
We encouraged people currently serving to stay on the job. We made lists of likely prospects. I encouraged department superintendents as they helped me with the task.
But as each new church year began, there were always a few slots unfilled, always a few classrooms without the volunteer teachers and helpers we needed. I can remember sitting in the back during Sunday-morning worship and scanning every pew. Had I missed someone who’d be willing to work?
Planning Ahead When Recruiting Church Volunteers
The experience taught me some things about recruiting volunteers, but I learned even more when I talked with Susan Lawrence and Melissa Sandel in our September 17 Beyond the Standard BlogTalk Radio interview.
For one thing, annual panic should not be the norm.
“There’s a difference between managing and leading,” Melissa Sandel said. “Managing is dealing with today today. Leading is planning for tomorrow today. There are times when you just have to get through Sunday. But that doesn’t mean you don’t have a plan to keep yourself from getting into those fixes.”
One strategy is to focus on times of the year when people are more likely to volunteer. At West Side Christian Church where Sandel serves as director of ministries, those times include the beginning of the new school year, the beginning of the calendar year, and right before Easter.
Susan Lawrence added that sometimes a church has trouble finding enough workers because of trying to do too much. (In retrospect, that may have been my recruiting problem.) Lawrence, a speaker and writer from Taylorville, Illinois, suggested church leaders ask, “Are we just trying to keep programs going? Are we being wise stewards of the people we have?”
Matching Volunteers with the Right Roles
Sandel set forth a big-picture strategy for recruiting the volunteers a church needs: Find people “wired to do what you’re asking them to do.” Cast vision: “You’re not just filling holes”; you sell the “why” and then the “what.” Explain to them “how their role fits into the big picture of what your church is trying to accomplish.”
And she added that good recruiting can lead to developing more than dependable volunteers. “When you onboard them well, and then you care for them and you equip them over the long haul, they become great recruiters for you.”
Lawrence said sometimes the recruiter’s job is to help a potential volunteer say no instead of yes. Sandel agreed. “Part of recruiting is helping people connect with the role that’s the right fit for them,” she said.
Hopefully I’ll do a better job of that whenever I’m in a recruiter’s role again. Before that, I need to listen again to the practical voices of experience in this Beyond the Standard episode. It ought to be required listening for anyone recruiting local church volunteers.
Find this podcast at http://bit.ly/1OyTTxx.
For 160 years Christian Standard has served the churches of the Restoration Movement. Your gift keeps articles like this one free for every church leader.
Keep reading
More in Church Leadership
From the archive
Christian Standard has covered this since 1866.











