23 November, 2024

Plausible Deniability

by | 29 July, 2015 | 0 comments

By Jim Tune

In the United Kingdom, members of Parliament have long been allowed to bill taxpayers for the expense of maintaining a second home because they are required to spend time in both London and their home districts. The office responsible for deciding what was reasonable approved nearly every request. Consequently British members of Parliament (MPs) treated it like a big blank check. And because their expenses were hidden from the public, MPs thought they had it made, until a newspaper printed a leaked copy of those expense claims in 2009.

Not surprisingly, the MPs had behaved abominably. Many of them declared their second home to be whichever one was due for major and lavish renovations (including dredging the moats). When the renovations were completed, they simply redesignated their primary home as their secondary home and renovated that one too, sometimes selling the newly renovated home for a huge profit.

Late night comedians are grateful for the never-ending stream of scandals like this one coming from political centers of power. But are the rest of us any better than our leaders?

Psychologists have done extensive research on the effects of “plausible deniability.” In one study, subjects performed a task and were given a slip of paper and a verbal confirmation of how much they were to be paid. But when they took the slip to another room to receive their pay, the cashier misread one digit and handed them too much money. Only 20 percent spoke up to correct the mistake.

July29_MT_JNThe story changed, however, when the cashier asked them if the payment was correct. In that case 60 percent said “no” and returned the extra money. Being asked directly removes plausible deniability. If a direct lie was required to keep the money, people were three times more likely to be honest.

In his book Predictably Irrational, Dan Ariely describes a series of studies in which participants had the opportunity to earn more money by claiming to have solved more math problems than they really did. Ariely summarized his findings like this: “When given the opportunity, many honest people will cheat. In fact, rather than finding that a few bad apples were weighting the averages, we discovered that the majority of people cheated, and they cheated just a little bit.”

Curiously, people didn”t try to get away with as much as they could. Rather, they cheated only up to the point where they themselves could no longer find a justification that would preserve their belief in their own honesty!

Ariely said conscious reasoning functions like a press secretary who automatically justifies any position taken by the president. Aided by our “press secretary,” we are able to lie and cheat frequently, and then cover it up so effectively that we convince even ourselves.

How ready we are to excuse the sin in our own lives, while condemning it in others. The heart is deceitful. George MacDonald famously said, “I understand God”s patience with the wicked, but I do wonder how He can be so patient with the pious.” I can justify most of my “little” sins, but every sin comes from the same tree. How would life change if all of us were harsh with ourselves in the matter of sin and compassionate to everyone else?

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Latest Articles

Ministry Help Wanted

Recent postings: A director of campus ministry is needed at the University of Illinois (Urbana-Champaign). Stillwater (Pa.) Christian Church is looking for both a lead pastor and a youth pastor. Lexington (Ohio) Church of Christ is seeking a full-time senior minister. Norwin Christian Church in North Huntingdon, Pa., needs a full-time worship minister. Lycoming Christian Church in Linden, Pa., is seeking a minister of children, youth, and young adults. Michigan City (Ind.) Christian Church needs a senior minister. And more . . .

Stories

By taking these symbols of Jesus’ body and blood, we announce we believe there really was a Jesus, and he really did die for us and carried all our sins down to a grave . . .

Documentary Highlights Christian Response to Pandemics

Southeast Christian Church’s “Purpose in Pandemics” is a documentary that follows the response of the church to pandemics throughout history. The “Purpose in Pandemics” website also includes a study guide for small groups and individuals.

Used of God

I soaked up Sam Stone’s wit and wisdom during our lunches together. Afterward, I’d take notes about our conversations. After hearing of his passing, inspired by his wordsmithing, I felt compelled to share just a small part of his story.

Sam E. Stone: ‘He Tried to Speak the Truth in Love’

In memory and appreciation of our former editor, Sam E. Stone, who died early this week, we share this 2011 column from Christian Standard’s archives in which Sam discussed four Scripture verses significant to his life.

Elliott Library ‘Cornerstone’ Laid

Three Bibles of historical significance to Cincinnati Christian University were the first books place on the shelves during relocation of the George Mark Elliott Library.

The Death of Evil

Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. saw in minority groups’ struggles for social equality in America a parallel with Israel’s bondage in Egypt. King envisioned God’s goodness would deliver the U.S. from the evil of segregation.

Mark Scott’s Greatest Kingdom Impact

Since I first enrolled at Ozark Christian College, Mark Scott has been my kingdom hero, and I’m not the only young preacher Mark has shaped. Over his 35 years at OCC, Mark has inspired generations of students.

‘Have We Plans for 1921?’

“All the Standard asks is the opportunity to serve, and it yearns to render in 1921 the greatest, finest, and best service of its history. . . .”

CCLF Concluding Strong First Year in Greater Cincinnati

In its first full year, the Christian Church Leadership Foundation has accomplished much to ensure Christian education and resources would continue to be available to people in the Greater Cincinnati area.

News Briefs for Dec. 9

Items from Timber Lake Christian Church (Moberly, Mo.), Choateville Christian Church (Frankfort, Ky.), Johnson University, and more.

My Counsel for Young Preachers

If I were counseling an aspiring young preacher fresh out of Bible college or seminary, champing at the bit to lead in the church, I would offer these three bits of advice.

My Memories of Marshall Leggett

By Ben Merold
As I think about Marshall Leggett, who passed away on March 2 at age 90, two personal experiences keep coming to my mind . . .

Powell Quintuplets Graduating from High School

When the Powell quintuplets were born in 2001, all of Kentucky celebrated, including Southeast Christian Church, where the Powells are longtime members. Now the quints are 18 and are all headed to the same university.

Reentry: It May Be Harder Than We Think

When the COVID-19 crisis eases, I anticipate that reentry is going to be harder than some people think. Churches, especially, need to prepare for this.

November 24 Study | Free at Last

If there is anything that should cause us to give thanks this week it is that God has provided an eternal home for us.

November 24 Application | No More

Sin’s devastating effects have plagued this fallen world ever since the Garden of Eden, but “Christ redeemed us from the curse of the law by becoming a curse for us” (Galatians 3:13).

November 24 | Discovery Questions

These Discovery Questions are for use with this week’s Lookout Bible Lesson, “The Battle is the Lord’s” (Revelation 21:1-8; 22:1-7, 18-20), by Mark Scott.

Our Gated Community

The Lord’s presence will sustain us whenever the “gates of Hades” and their leader (Satan) pose a threat.

Follow Us