Church Leadership

Your Church: a Boys Club?

Mark A. Taylor examines subtle gender bias in church leadership, drawing on workplace observations and women's ministry experiences to question unequal expectations, limited mentoring opportunities, and the persistence of informal boys' clubs.

gender bias in church leadership
In brief

Gender Bias in Church Leadership: Recognizing Subtle Barriers

Gender bias in church leadership can appear through comments, workplace expectations, and unequal access to mentoring. Mark A. Taylor draws on Joanne Lipman’s observations about women at work and responses from women serving in ministry. He challenges Christian leaders to consider whether informal workplace cultures create barriers even when churches affirm women’s contributions.

  • Comments intended as compliments can reveal underlying assumptions about women’s abilities.
  • Women serving in ministry describe challenges involving mentoring, workplace expectations, and access to leadership circles.
  • Church leaders are encouraged to examine whether their organizational cultures create unequal opportunities.

Many, many years ago I bumped into the president of a parachurch ministry who was considering a woman for an executive role with his organization.

“You know,” he said to me, as if he couldn’t quite believe the statement he was about to make. “She’s really sharp.” She would be the first woman to serve (with distinction, I might add) with such authority at his institution.

That incident reminds me of a Christian college teacher who wrote on a student’s paper, “You write really well for a woman.”

Recognizing Subtle Gender Bias at Work

Admittedly, both these incidents occurred decades ago. But a report by Joanne Lipman in The Wall Street Journal says such words still are spoken, and not only in church settings.

Feb17_MT_JNIn her piece, “Women at Work: a Guide for Men,” she mentions comments she’s received that were intended as compliments but, like the quotes above, were really insults. She classes some of these as “benevolent sexism.” To a mother: “You’ve got two little kids? How do you do it?” From a colleague: “She’s a very accomplished woman leader.” Why not just say “a very accomplished leader”?

I can only begin to summarize her piece here. Its whole premise is, “I’m not against men. I love men. But women cannot make happen all the change necessary in the workplace today. Men need to initiate some changes.”

Some of her points:

  • Women have been conditioned to ask questions or apologize for their ideas rather than assert a straightforward suggestion. This puts them at a disadvantage in a meeting.
  • Women tend not to ask for a promotion or a raise—or even to be aware they deserve one—as soon as men do.
  • Women must earn the respect of their colleagues; men assume they have it when they walk into the room.
  • Women may cry more easily than most men. They still deserve honest feedback on their work.
  • Women may not be ready for some tasks or roles when their children are small. This doesn’t mean they’re incapable of handling more after the children are older.
  • Women tend to collaborate more than men, which some men misunderstand as weakness.

Women in Ministry and the Leadership Inner Circle

I sent the piece to a number of women who lead ministry and asked them if they resonated with it. Are problems like these facing women in church work settings as they are in the corporate world?

Those who answered me, in a word, said “Yes.” Not that every problem mentioned by Lipman has been experienced by every woman who responded. But their comments reveal a church workplace that often presents far different experiences—and opportunities—for women to lead than for men.

Rather than write one too-long column here, I’ll save most of these comments for next week’s column. But to get us started, let me quote just one woman who comments from the center of one megachurch’s ministry.

“At our church we say we are all for women in leadership and we want more women to step up and lead and teach,” she said. “But we kind of have a boys club going on where it is a little harder for women to be mentored and a part of the inner circle.

“Many meetings start with sport references and conversations.

“If a woman feels passionate about something, we might cry. That is very difficult for any of the guys to understand; they feel she is just too emotional. But if a guy gets mad about something, it’s accepted.”

I’m sure not every Christian leader—man or woman—will agree on the scope of this problem or the solutions to it. That doesn’t mean we shouldn’t consider it.

Have the male leaders at your church formed a “boys club” even as they’ve given women significant responsibilities for the church’s ministry? Next week I’ll introduce you to a few more women who feel something like that is happening where they serve.

Mark A. Taylor
Author: Mark A. Taylor

Mark A. Taylor, who served as Christian Standard editor from 2003 to 2017, retired in June 2017 after almost 41 years with Standard Publishing (Christian Standard Media).

Sponsored

Logo_Renew.orgNetwork-05 2560x1340
About the author

Mark A. Taylor

Mark A. Taylor, who served as Christian Standard editor from 2003 to 2017, retired in June 2017 after almost 41 years with Standard Publishing (Christian Standard Media).

More from Mark A. Taylor →
Christian Standard is reader-supported

For 160 years Christian Standard has served the churches of the Restoration Movement. Your gift keeps articles like this one free for every church leader.

Sponsored

Filament Bible1200x675

Keep reading

More in Church Leadership

From the archive

Christian Standard has covered this since 1866.

Subscribe
Notify of
0 Comments
Get Online Access to Be Seen, Be Heard
A Two Hour Online Visibility Course for Churches

Be Seen Be Heard Online Course - Christian Standard

Learn how to turn the sermons you’re already preaching into searchable, shareable content that helps people discover and connect with your local church. Access Be Seen, Be Heard on demand with Wes Woodell and Trey Sheneman. A two hour course for preachers, church media and website teams, and anyone who wants to help their church reach more people online.

No, thank you.
Transactions are 100% secure.


No, thank you.
Help Keep Christian Standard Free & Accessible with a Tax Deductible Donation

We can do more together!

Every gift makes a difference!

No, thank you.
100% secure transactions - receipts provided.
Does Your Church Want to Support Christian Standard?

Would your church consider including support for Christian Standard in its annual missions budget? Your support would help us not only continue the 160-year legacy of this unifying ministry, but also expand the free resources, cooperative opportunities, and practical guidance we provide to strengthen churches in the U.S. and around the world.

We can do more together!

Every gift makes a difference!

No, thank you.
100% secure transactions - receipts provided.
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x