The Time to Refine Our Focus
Pastor Caleb Kaltenbach challenges Christians to respond to the legalization of gay marriage with grace and truth, emphasizing identity in Jesus, meaningful conversations, and the difference between acceptance and approval.

Caleb Kaltenbach on Gay Marriage: Grace, Truth, and the Church’s Response
Caleb Kaltenbach on gay marriage offers a perspective centered on grace, truth, and the importance of Christian identity. Following the Supreme Court’s decision legalizing gay marriage, Kaltenbach encourages Christians to focus on identity before behavior and to approach conversations about sexuality with compassion while maintaining their theological convictions. Drawing from his upbringing in the gay community and his experience as a pastor, he challenges churches to build meaningful relationships rather than simply make points. His message emphasizes the difference between acceptance and approval and the opportunity for Christians to demonstrate love in a changing culture.
- Caleb Kaltenbach believes Christians should emphasize identity in Jesus before addressing questions of behavior and sexuality.
- Churches can maintain their theological convictions about marriage and sexuality while treating people with genuine love, dignity, and compassion.
- Meaningful conversations and personal relationships provide opportunities to demonstrate grace and truth rather than focusing only on disagreements.
The Internet is buzzing with reactions to last week’s Supreme Court decision legalizing gay marriage. Advocates are adding the #LoveWins hashtag to every tweet, and Christian leaders are urging the church not to be discouraged in the face of what many view as a terrible loss.

Amid all the chatter, Caleb Kaltenbach’s perspective offers a voice as refreshing as it is calm.
Caleb Kaltenbach on Identity Before Behavior
“Some say this is the defining issue of the day,” he said when I interviewed him last week at the North American Christian Convention. “But I believe the church is getting it wrong.” We should focus on identity before we address behavior, Kaltenbach believes. “We must point people to define themselves by Jesus and not their sexuality,” he said.
Kaltenbach, whose new book, Messy Grace, will be released in October, writes from a unique perspective. His parents divorced when he was 2 years old, and each entered the gay lifestyle. Kaltenbach grew up surrounded by his mother’s friends and activities in the gay community and learned to believe what she repeatedly told him: “Christians hate gays.”
When he was 16 he began attending a Bible study to disprove Christianity, but instead became a Christian himself. Soon he had committed himself to a lifetime of vocational Christian service, but he’s never forgotten the pain, problems, and possibilities among the many gay people he has known.
Holding Grace and Truth Together
Today, with his wife and two children, he serves as pastor with Discovery Church in Simi Valley, California. “We want to be known as a church that struggles with the tension between grace and truth,” he said. “We can stick to our theological convictions and still be loving.”
He quoted Andy Stanley, who says, “Some churches like to make points. It’s easier to make a point than to make a difference. It’s easier to take a firm stand than to have a conversation.”
Perhaps the Supreme Court decision will make more Christians willing to have conversations with gay people, embracing, as Kaltenbach says, the difference between acceptance and approval.
It’s not that the world is changing, he says. “The world has already changed.” We can’t go back, but we can go forward, convincing practicing homosexuals—and every other kind of sinner we meet in our workplaces and neighborhoods—that Christians do not hate them.
Our focus is not on any particular human failing. Kaltenbach reminds us that in our time, as in every age, Jesus is the issue of the day. But perhaps now, as never before in our lifetimes, we have new responsibility as well as opportunity to lift him up and demonstrate him well.
Watch the full interview with Caleb Kaltenbach by clicking here.
For 160 years Christian Standard has served the churches of the Restoration Movement. Your gift keeps articles like this one free for every church leader.
Keep reading
More in Ethics & Moral Issues

Should Christian Organizations Use Non-Disclosure Agreements?

A FEMINIST ARGUES OUR CULTURE OF SEXUAL LIBERATION HARMS WOMEN AND MOSTLY SERVES PRIVILEGED MEN

AI Companions and Christian Faith: How the Church Should Respond to Artificial Intimacy
From the archive
Christian Standard has covered this since 1866.








There was an issue in the early church that had the potential to destroy it and that was the case of Ananias and Sapphira recorded for us in Acts 5. Their sin of lying to the Holy Spirit and attempting to deceive the church was serious enough for God to put them to death. Covetousness, deceit, pride and hypocrisy would have conceivably crippled the church at that early stage. Love and grace was not extended to them. The sin was nipped in the bud.
Several issues today stand out in our culture with the potential to destroy the church and they are all connected to sexual sin; fornication, adultery, divorce, abortion and homosexuality. Abortion for the most part has not been accepted in the church but the other four and most recently homosexuality has made inroads and many churches and denominations are succumbing. Treating the sin of homosexuality with kid gloves and outstretched arms will only make the situation worse. I believe this is one of those times where love and grace cannot be extended to those who practice this sin. We need to strongly condemn the practice and preach repentance. If we let the culture redefine both morality and the gospel the death of the church is not far behind.
To be sure the world has changed, but the church’s definition of sexual morality, sin and the gospel cannot! Time to take a firm stand people. Don’t be afraid of persecution. Don’t sit this one out in silence like we’ve done with the abortion issue. Make a noise. Preach Christlikeness. There is no reason we can’t reverse the trend to redefine sexual morality in our churches and in the culture at large. Prayer won’t get it done. Bold and firm preaching will.
David I think you forgot Matthew 12:31 that states that every sin and blasphemy will be forgiven except blasphemy of the Holy Spirit that is why God made the consequence clear. We get in trouble when we start judging which sins the church excepts and those it doesn’t.